The morality of toture suspected criminals and terrorists

Advertisement Once again, we are faced with a terrible choice of evils. President Bill Clinton gave a similar answer: Our enemies may laugh at our hand wringing, but it is the very inhumanity and chaos, the inability to use diplomacy and appreciate peace, that we disdain in them and struggle against when it is directed towards us and the innocent among them.

I am afraid that many American torture advocates would not have a problem with any of the above, even if it might only save just one American life. Obama agreed with Hillary Clinton that there should be an absolute prohibition against tortureeven if there The morality of toture suspected criminals and terrorists a a ticking bomb — a situation we have, fortunately, not faced.

Recognizing the potential for abuse during interrogations, U. Christians especially are being hypocritical since they have historically condemned situation ethics and the decline of moral absolutes. But is this the right thing to do. Yes, the crimes of terrorists are many.

Ancient Greek courts placed great faith in testimony obtained through torture of slaves. On the other hand, some are able to withhold information and some, especially character neurotics, are able to lie.

To gain the political and economic advantages of membership, Turkey attempted to develop torture techniques that leave no medical trace. She had personally killed 32 Turkish National Police officers The right not to be tortured or mistreated is not a luxury to be dispensed with in difficult times, but the very essence of a society worth defending.

What if the suspected American terrorist becomes disabled or dies as a result of the torture. Once torture is allowed, setting limits is extraordinarily difficult.

The Legal Prohibition Against Torture

I invite any reader who discovers a problem with my argument to point it out to me in the comment section of this blog. If the end is gaining information that may save American lives, then why not. CIA medical personnel were present when waterboarding was taking place, the taskforce says.

As a moral matter, I am categorically opposed to torture, without exception. To cover up torture, physicians falsify health certificates, autopsy reports, and death certificates. But why stop with suspects in police custody. Prior to interrogation, some captives have been beaten.

Access Denied

Torture spreads to foreign governments through exchange of torture technology. If our intuition about the wrongness of torture is born of an aversion to how people generally behave while being tortured, we should note that this particular infelicity could be circumvented pharmacologically, because paralytic drugs make it unnecessary for screaming ever to be heard or writhing seen.

Supreme Court has condemned the use of force amounting to torture or other forms of ill treatment during interrogations, including such practices as whipping, slapping, depriving a victim of food, water, or sleep, keeping him naked or in a small cell for prolonged periods, holding a gun to his head, or threatening him with mob violence.

Is it morally permissible to torture a suspected terrorist who is a woman in an attempt to gain information that may save American lives. Other religions have their particular holy books. You don't have the right EVEN if someone deserved to be tortured, which many who are illegally tortured do not, nobody has the right to deliberately harm another human being with the intention of causing the maximum physical and emotional pain.

Criminal acts that are jus cogens are subject to universal jurisdiction, meaning that any state can exercise its jurisdiction, regardless of where the crime took place, the nationality of the perpetrator or the nationality of the victim.

A choice of evils

But that temptation must be vigorously resisted. Torture is universally condemned, and whatever its actual practice, no country publicly supports torture or opposes its eradication.

And may any form of torture be used or are there certain forms of torture that are off limits for suspects in police custody. Establishment of a Torture Interrogation Unit Political scientist Harold William Rood, who for ten years taught field interrogation of prisoners of war in military intelligence schools, explained the institutionalization challenge as follows.

What about American woman and children. Americas manual, call for the services of physicians and psychiatrists.

A choice of evils

Is it morally permissible to torture a suspected terrorist even if it results in his death in an attempt to gain information that may save American lives. In the aftermath of Abu Ghraib, this is not a comfortable position to have publicly adopted. Might we not be tempted to call it a "truth pill" in the end.

In Defense of Torture

Given this state of affairs--in particular, given that there is still time to prevent an imminent atrocity--it seems that subjecting this unpleasant fellow to torture may be justifiable. And yet, these developments do not shed much light on the ethics of torturing people like Osama bin Laden when we get them in custody.

They also failed to comply with recommendations from the army surgeon general on reporting abuse of detainees. For example, how imminent must the attack be to trigger the exception and justify torture - an hour, a week, a year. Targeted killings Several basic positions have emerged.

The animal instinct model ultimately fails because the physiological experience of pain is mediated by individual and cultural interpretation.

Of some suspected terrorists believed to have been “rendered” over the past six years, 39 remain unaccounted for, Human Rights Watch, a New York-based lobby, says. The morality of toture: Suspected Criminals And Terrorists. The principle of torture has been brought back into the forefront of philosophical debate following the September 11th terrorist attacks.

In August53% of Americans said the use of torture to question suspected terrorists could be often or sometimes justified, while 42% said it could only rarely be justified or not justified at all.

Debating the Morality of Torture. more than 6 in 10 white evangelical Protestants agree that "the use of torture against suspected terrorists in order to gain important information can be. CIA made doctors torture suspected terrorists after 9/11, taskforce finds Doctors were asked to torture detainees for intelligence gathering, and unethical practices continue, review concludes.

Debating the Morality of Torture. more than 6 in 10 white evangelical Protestants agree that "the use of torture against suspected terrorists in order to gain important information can be.

The morality of toture suspected criminals and terrorists
Rated 4/5 based on 76 review